
The U.S. Supreme Court‘s current term has been a bit lacking so far when it comes to high-profile cases. I don’t mean to imply any lack of important cases—indeed, just last week the Court heard oral arguments in a major case about holding federal officials to account for constitutional rights violations—rather, what I mean is that we haven’t really yet seen the kind of headline-grabbing legal disputes that capture national attention and send political activists into overdrive.
But that may be about to change. On Friday, the justices agreed to hear arguments in Mullin v. Refugee and Immigrant Center for Education and Legal Services, a case arising from the Trump administration’s unilateral executive suspension of asylum protections for immigrants at the U.S.-Mexico border. Much like last term’s big showdown over tariffs, the key question in this case is whether President Donald Trump is guilty of wielding authority that properly belongs to a different branch of the federal government. At the very least, a SCOTUS fight over immigration and presidential overreach in the waning age of Trump has the makings of a blockbuster case.
Under federal immigration law, persons who are unlawfully present in the United States are subject to removal proceedings. At the same time, federal law also says that such persons may attempt to obtain relief from removal by seeking asylum, or by seeking withholding from removal, under either the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) or the Convention Against Torture, on the grounds that they would face persecution or torture if deported.
The Trump administration, however, asserts that it may
The Trump administration, however, asserts that it may unilaterally suspend the asylum and withholding from removal protections for persons who unlawfully crossed the U.S.-Mexico border. According to a January 2025 presidential proclamation, “the President’s inherent powers to control the borders of the United States, including those deriving from his authority to control the foreign affairs of the United States, necessarily include the ability to prevent the physical entry of aliens involved in an invasion into the United States, and to rapidly repatriate them to an alternative location.”
In April 2026, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit rejected this executive argument. “Our task is to determine whether Congress has granted the Executive the authority to remove foreign individuals present in the United States without adhering to the removal procedures or providing the substantive removal protections that Congress prescribed in the INA,” the appellate court said. “We conclude that the INA’s text, structure, and history make clear that in supplying power to suspend entry by Presidential proclamation, Congress did not intend to grant the Executive the expansive removal authority it asserts.”
It is that loss before the D.C. Circuit that the Trump administration has now persuaded the Supreme Court to review.
To reviewing the statutory question decided
In addition to reviewing the statutory question decided by the D.C. Circuit, it is possible the Supreme Court may also wade into the underlying argument over what counts as an “invasion” for constitutional purposes, as Trump’s assertion of “inherent” executive power in this case rests on Trump’s view that the president is doubly empowered to act in this manner because an “invasion” is occurring at the southern border. That view from Trump is a version of the oft-heard argument that normal constitutional limits on the president should be weakened or even removed when the president is acting in the name of foreign affairs or national security.
My guess is that the Supreme Court will avoid this constitutional minefield and stick to the safer grounds of statutory interpretation. But an outbreak of broader constitutional conflict is possible.
